The roadside sign at Hickory Hollow gives you three clues about what’s inside. Beneath the yellow lettering on weathered wood are a red crab, an ear of corn and a white pig. By the time Lisa and I sat down, I’d made up my mind to order bacon, lettuce and tomato. Lisa went straight for the crab cake. We’d come to a barbecue restaurant and ordered around the smoker, which turned out to be a fine way to discover just how much this Ellenton restaurant does well.
An Old Florida dining room
Inside, there’s knotty wood paneling, bright blue trim and a patterned ceiling with fans overhead. The table in front of us had an inset of glazed tiles in rust, cream and blue. There’s an aquarium by the front window, string lights above the counter and a collection of pig figurines among the odds and ends. Throw in the drinks in translucent blue tumblers with lime wedges, and there was plenty for my camera before the food came out.

It felt like Old Florida to me, down to the pleasure of noticing some small detail the longer you sit. The room has the look of a place where somebody liked a picture and found a wall for it, then did the same thing again a few years later. Hickory Hollow has been family-owned since 1984, according to the restaurant. Four decades is plenty of time for a dining room to develop a personality of its own.
That easygoing feeling carried through to the service. Our servers were genuinely friendly, and so was everyone else we encountered. I notice when the warmth extends beyond the person taking the order. It makes a meal feel like a visit, and it’s part of why I’d send someone looking for an independent restaurant in Manatee County here.
A proper BLT and a standout crab cake
My BLT came on thick toast, browned deep in the center and golden around the edges. It was cut into triangles, each held together with a blue-tipped toothpick. Broad green leaves spilled out from the toast, and the bacon reached right to the edge. A paper tray of fried okra took up most of the other half of the yellow plate. There were thick, skin-on potato wedges on the table, too.

A BLT is one of those orders that sounds so straightforward you can overlook it when a menu is full of smoked meats and seafood. I was glad I didn’t. There’s a particular satisfaction in biting through substantial toast into bacon, lettuce and tomato, each ingredient doing exactly what you ordered it for. Add a side like fried okra, with those irregular little rounds wearing their golden crusts, and you have a lunch I’d happily repeat.
Lisa’s Maryland crab cake was the standout at our table. It arrived golden brown, with pieces of crab visible along the edges and flecks of seasoning across the surface. Two round, deep-golden corn fritters sat behind it, with coleslaw and a little cup of red sauce alongside. Hickory Hollow says it seasons its cakes with Old Bay, grills them and uses a light hand with the filler. The menu offers a single cake or a two-cake platter. Lisa loved hers, and I could see why she’d order it again even with so much else to try.

What Hickory Hollow is known for
The pulled pork is the place to start if you want to understand Hickory Hollow’s barbecue. The kitchen serves it two ways. The traditional version gets a tomato-based barbecue sauce. The house specialty draws from eastern North Carolina, with hickory-smoked pork seasoned with sweet vinegar. The Carolina-style sandwich comes topped with coleslaw. Sarasota Magazine singles out the restaurant’s Carolina-style barbecue and its comfort-food sides, two reasons I’d make the return trip.
The barbecue menu goes further with St. Louis-style ribs, char-grilled baby backs and smoked turkey. I’d be tempted to try the two pork preparations side by side, an option on the combination menu. Another combination could put the Carolina pork and a crab cake on the same plate, which strikes me as the most direct way to sample both sides of the kitchen. The seafood menu also lists Southern-style fried catfish and fried Key West pink shrimp.
The sides could send me back on their own. The restaurant describes a rotating selection of roughly two dozen vegetables and accompaniments. Along with fried okra, the possibilities include stewed tomatoes, squash and cheese casserole, collard greens, black-eyed peas and rutabagas. At our table, lima beans came in their own little bowl, and mashed potatoes held a pool of brown gravy. I like seeing that much thought go into the decision of what to put beside the main dish. The restaurant even offers a vegetable platter if your eye keeps going back to the sides.
Then there’s Brunswick stew, a slow-cooked mix of chicken, pork, corn, lima beans, potatoes, onions and tomatoes that Hickory Hollow calls a house favorite. You can order a bowl as a meal with four corn fritters. The restaurant also lists homemade desserts such as cobbler, bread pudding and bourbon pecan pie. I could see coming back for a bowl of stew and whatever cobbler is available that day.
Worth the stop in Ellenton
If you’re spending the day in Manatee County and want to work in a meal with some local character, Hickory Hollow is an easy detour along U.S. 301. The weathered sign is the landmark I’d tell you to look for. Once you’re inside, give yourself time to look around and ask what vegetables are on that day. A good side can settle the question of what to order when you’ve narrowed the main dish down to three.
I came away remembering the toast on my BLT, the browned edges of Lisa’s crab cake and the way the staff made us feel at home. Next time I want to try the Carolina pork. Of course, if Lisa orders the crab cake again, I may have to get one of those combination platters so there’s a crab cake on my side of the table, too.
Hickory Hollow · 4705 U.S. Route 301, Ellenton, Florida · 941-722-3932

Leave a Reply