Eat • Wander

Tequila’s Mexican Restaurant in Palmetto Gets the Little Things Right

Beef burrito and crisp-shell beef taco with rice and beans
Share this feature and help others explore their world!

Cold, crisp salsa, a memorable chile relleno and traditional Mexican music make Tequila’s Mexican Restaurant in Palmetto worth a return visit.

Share this feature and help others explore their world!

The first thing I’d go back for at Tequila’s Mexican Restaurant in Palmetto is the salsa. We ordered a beef burrito, a beef taco and a chile relleno, and I’d happily order all three again. But that salsa was cold, crisp and refreshing, with enough flavor to make me pause and pay attention. It’s easy to treat salsa as something to eat while you wait for the meal. Here, it was one of the best things we ate.

Tequila’s is at 639 10th Street East in Palmetto, Florida. Lisa and I found a colorful, festive dining room with traditional Mexican music playing. I loved that the music belonged in the room. So many restaurants seem to put on whatever playlist is handy, and you can spend half the meal wondering who picked it. Here, what we heard fit what we saw and what we came to eat. It’s a small decision that made a real difference to how much we enjoyed being there.

Brick storefront and entrance to Tequila’s Mexican Restaurant at 639 10th Street East in Palmetto
The entrance to Tequila’s at 639 10th Street East in Palmetto.

The salsa deserves its own paragraph. Maybe two.

Red salsa and a basket of tortilla chips
Cold red salsa and a basket of tortilla chips.

Cold salsa can be refreshing and still leave you waiting for the flavor to show up. This one had plenty of it right away. “Crisp” is the word I kept coming back to, both for the way it tasted and for how cleanly it cut through the richer food on the table. It was the kind of salsa I wanted another taste of even after the burrito, taco and relleno had given me plenty else to pay attention to.

What I liked most was how well it worked with everything we ordered. After a bite of beef burrito, that cool salsa made me ready for another. With the taco, it gave a familiar combination an extra lift. And alongside the chile relleno, it woke up my palate enough to go right back to the pepper. If you asked me a week later what I remembered most clearly about our meal, I’d probably say “how cold that salsa was” before I even got to what we ordered.

A beef burrito, a beef taco and a chile relleno

A beef burrito is one of my favorite things to order when I’m getting to know a Mexican restaurant. I know almost immediately whether I’m going to want to finish it. At Tequila’s, the beef had enough flavor to hold my attention on its own, which is exactly what I want from a burrito. Every few bites, I’d go back to the salsa. There was something particularly satisfying about following a substantial bite of burrito with something that tasted that bright and cool.

The beef taco came in a crisp shell with shredded lettuce and cheese, and there were rice and beans alongside the burrito and taco. I liked the taco for its directness. It tasted like something I’d come back and order on its own, especially if I wanted a lighter meal and still wanted that salsa. If Taco Bell is your reference point for a beef taco, this is a good place to reset it. The flavor here is what I’d go to a Mexican restaurant for.

Chile relleno topped with red sauce, with melted cheese visible
The chile relleno, with red sauce and melted cheese.

The chile relleno was the dish I was happiest we included. With two beef dishes already on the table, the pepper gave the meal a different flavor and pace. It came blanketed in red sauce, with the stem still attached and melted cheese peeking out at the edges. A relleno has a richness that makes me want to take my time with it, and I like being able to taste the chile itself as I work my way through the dish. Of the three things we ordered, this is the one I’d point to if someone asked what made the meal feel especially authentic to us.

A dining room with a point of view

Tequila’s dining room with colorful papel picado and pink blossoms
Papel picado, pink blossoms and festive garlands in the dining room.

I’d put the music right alongside the food as a reason we enjoyed Tequila’s. I’ve been in plenty of places where I liked what was on the plate and wished somebody would change what was coming out of the speakers. Here, I was glad somebody had made a choice. Colorful papel picado hung overhead, pink blossoms rose behind the brick divider, and traditional Mexican music gave the room a festive feel that suited the food. I’d take that over a radio mix of rap and country any time I sit down to a meal like this.

There’s also a lot to like about going out for three dishes you already know and having them remind you why you order them in the first place. Lisa and I ate a beef burrito, a beef taco and a chile relleno. I could send a friend to Tequila’s with that exact order and feel good about it. Each dish earned its place, and I especially liked that we could go back and forth among them and keep finding a reason to reach for the salsa.

I’d go back to Tequila’s the next time we’re in Palmetto. I might try something different from the menu, although I’d have a hard time passing up the chile relleno. Either way, I know what I want on the table first. Give me that salsa cold, keep the music playing, and give me a minute to decide on the rest.

Leave a Reply